Massachusetts Immigration Lawyer Blog

In Boston, Massachusetts, I recently spoke at the American Immigration Lawyers Association (AILA) Conference on Immigration Law.  The topic was citizenship and naturalization.

Several immigration lawyers from Massachusetts have sent me follow up questions. In response, here are a few tips that will help you successfully handle an application for naturalization, N-400.

Research your client's criminal history before submitting the N-400 application for naturalization by requesting an FBI rap sheet or Interstate Identification Index ("III") and a Massachusetts CORI.  The FBI III is based on fingerprints.  My office fingerprints immigration clients in-house using this kit.  The Massachusetts CORI is based on name and date of birth, which is why it is essential to list on the form every possible spelling of your client's name, as well as aliases. Keep in mind that these records are notoriously inaccurate.  The final step is to track down criminal dispositions for all court appearances.  Remember: your job as an immigration lawyer isn't done until you have closely reviewed court-certified final criminal dispositions showing all docket sheets for each court appearance.

Selective Service and Citizenship.  For male naturalization applicants, failure to register for Selective Service for permanent residents between the age of 19 and 26 bars a finding of good moral character during the requisite three or five year period but only if the applicant knowingly or willfully failed to register.  In my experience as an immigration lawyer, many clients mistakenly believe that they forgot to register for Selective Service when, in fact, they actually did.  If your client says that he never registered with Selective Service, you should double check to make sure he's right.  You can use the Selective Service Online Registration Verification available here. If your client's Selective Service information is not found, this does not necessarily mean that he failed to register. You should then call the agency at 888-655-1825 to see if his registration is in the system. And, finally, to prepare for the naturalization interview, you should request a status of information letter from Selective Service.

Fill out the N-400 with meticulous attention to detail to avoid "false testimony."  Even the smallest mistake on the N-400 form could be used as an excuse to deny your immigration client's N-400.  As a matter of good moral character, an applicant for citizenship can be denied if, during the requisite period of time, he or she knowingly provides false or misleading information to an immigration officer for the purposes of obtaining an immigration benefit.  Using this legal standard, USCIS could construe inaccurate information on the naturalization application as a deliberate lie and, therefore, a ground for denial. This comes into play particularly when disclosing adverse information such as criminal appearances.

Good Moral Character: how to determine whether your client has met the standard.  To obtain US citizenship through the naturalization process, you ordinarily must show good moral character for 5 years or for 3 years if your claim is based on marriage to a US citizen.  If your client has a criminal conviction, it may be necessary to wait to file the N-400 until the date the offense was committed is outside the 3- or 5-year period.

Good luck.  If you need help from a Boston immigration lawyer who enjoys complex citizenship cases, call me at (617) 722-0005 or contact me anytime.

Boston area residents with final orders of deportation may request a stay of removal with U.S. Customs and Immigration Enforcement (ICE) by filing Form I-246 at its Burlington, Massachusetts immigration office.  In the past, there had been no filing fee for this immigration application.  But, apparently, the free ride is over.  Effective immediately, a filing fee of $155 must be paid with Form I-246 in cash, money order or cashier's check (no personal checks).

On behalf of the lawyers in my Boston immigration office, I say congratulations! You just got your green card and are now a lawful permanent resident of the United States! Below are some general tips to avoid future immigration problems and continue on a smooth path towards citizenship.

I-751, Petition to Remove Conditions on Residency--Get Ready! If you have a two-year green card (i.e., conditional residency based on marriage), remember that 90 days before the expiration of your green card, you and your spouse, together, will need to file a petition to remove the conditions on your permanent residency. This petition is called an I-751.  In order to get your I-751 petition approved, USCIS will expect you to submit extensive documentation to show that the underlying relationship between you and your spouse has been on-going since your I-485 was approved and that you continue to share your lives together.

Prepare for citizenship by recording your trips outside the U.S. If you travel outside the U.S. after you get your green card, write down the date that you left the U.S. and the date that you returned to the U.S for every trip you take after your I-485 is approved. You will need this information when you apply for citizenship. Some of my immigration clients mistakenly believe that their passport will contain stamps that will memorialize each of their trips abroad.  This is not necessarily true. These days, passports are machine-readable, and they often are scanned rather than stamped when you leave certain airports or when you cross the border via land to Canada. Thus, because your passport may not be stamped when you leave and enter the U.S., you cannot rely on it as an accurate record of your trips abroad. Keeping a record of your trips as you take them will save you time and effort when you apply for citizenship.

Don't "abandon" your green card. As a permanent resident, you certainly are not legally required to remain within Massachusetts. In fact, one of the great benefits of being a green card holder is that you are free to travel within the U.S. and internationally. But, if you want to keep your green card, only temporary trips outside the United States are permitted. As a permanent resident, you could have future immigration problems if you travel outside the United States frequently or if the duration of your trips abroad are lengthy. From my experience working with immigration clients in Boston, the most effective way to lose your green card is to move abroad. Take a look at your green card and you will see the words permanent resident card at the top. Remember, the green card is not permanent but does require you to reside permanently in the United States.You should avoid staying outside the U.S. for more than 6 months continuously. You should not remain outside the U.S. for an extended period of time without first consulting with an immigration lawyer in Boston.

If you have a green card, you must notify the Department of Homeland Security of any changes of address. As a green card holder, it is your responsibility to notify the Department of Homeland Security of any address changes. You can do this by filing Form AR-11. I recommend that you file Form AR-11 online through the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Service (USCIS, formerly the INS) website. Once you have submitted Form AR-11, keep a copy of it for your records. If you have a green card and also have an immigration application that is pending with USCIS, you must also separately notify USCIS of any changes of address by calling its National Customer Service Center at 800-375-5283.  As an immigration lawyer, I handle change of address notification for all of my immigration clients and maintain records of each address change.

Don't commit crimes! (especially during the first five years after you become a permanent resident)  Of course, it's generally a pretty bad idea to break the law.  But green card holders have no room for error.  Many people are shocked to discover the incredibly harsh immigration consequences of seemingly minor criminal offenses. Shoplifting, for instance, may be considered a relatively petty misdemeanor under Massachusetts law. But, if committed within the first five years of your status as a green card holder, a Massachusetts shoplifting conviction could result in your certain deportation from the United States without any chance for relief.

If you have ever appeared in a criminal court, do not travel outside the United States without first consulting with an immigration lawyer. I constantly meet with immigration clients in Boston who have criminal convictions and who mistakenly believe that one or all of their previous criminal cases were dismissed. Keep in mind that a Massachusetts district court judge may have told you that your criminal case was dismissed, and your criminal defense lawyer may have also told your that your criminal case will not show up on your record; but for immigration purposes, you may still have a criminal conviction!  Before you book your flight abroad, call me and set up an immigration consultation in my Boston office.

Again, congratulation on becoming a permanent resident. I hope these tips help guide you towards U.S. citizenship.

Boston, Massachusetts is beautiful and sunny on this fine Tax Day! Permanent residents, naturalization applicants and others seeking immigration benefits often ask me about tax issues.  As an immigration lawyer, I frankly admit that I know next to nothing about tax law.  But what I do understand are the immigration consequences of certain tax issues such as the following:

• Naturalization: if you want to apply for naturalization to become a US citizen, you first have to take care of your taxes.  If you failed to file a tax return or claimed to be a non-resident on your tax return, you have a potential problem. If you owe money for income taxes, your application for naturalization may not be approved unless you can provide U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) with proof that you have entered into a payment plan and that you are current on your payment pursuant to such a plan.  Remember:  tax avoidance is considered an issue of good moral character, which USCIS can use as grounds to deny your application for naturalization, N-400.

• Green card:  if you are a permanent resident, i.e., you have a green card, you are required to live in the United States.  If you move abroad, you could be deemed to have abandoned your green card.  Therefore, it is good idea to file an income tax return each year, if for no other reason than to document that you are, in fact, living in the U.S.  If you claim to be a non-resident on your taxes, it is considered a presumption that you have abandoned your lawful permanent resident status and could lead to removal proceedings in Immigration Court and, possible, deportation from the United States.
  

• Green Card through Marriage: if you are seeking a green card based on marriage to a US citizen or have a two-year green card, your tax returns are important pieces of evidence that USCIS looks at when determining whether your marriage is based on a bona fide relationship. It is essential that your tax return be filed jointly with your spouse and that the address on all your W-2s and your spouse's W-2s reflects the particular address where you and your spouse claim to be living together in marital bliss. I-751 applicants seeking a petition to remove the conditions on permanent residency will be expected to show joint tax returns.  If your immigration status is dependent on marriage and you are NOT able to file a tax return with your spouse, it is important to consult with an immigration lawyer.
  

• Affidavit of Support, I-864:  generally, if you file an affidavit of support, I-864, you must show that you have income equal to 125% of the poverty guideline for the appropriate household size.  The amount of income you have is generally judged based on your adjusted gross income on your Form 1040 for the 3 most recent tax years.  In an earlier blog post, I offered a few other suggestions regarding the I-864, affidavit of support.
  

• Citizenship vs. Green card--estate tax problem:  there are many, many good reasons for those with green cards to apply for US citizenship.  Consider that permanent residents are taxed unfavorably for estate purposes as compared with US citizens. The unlimited marital deduction is not allowed for transfers to legal permanent resident spouses.  Tragically, my best friend was diagnosed with brain cancer and past away last year leaving behind his Italian wife who was then a permanent resident. With the help of a kind USCIS immigration officer, I was able to help rush his wife's citizenship through the immigration system so that his wife could naturalize expeditiously.
  

• Out of Status? Undocumented? You should still pay taxes!  In the U.S., you have only three requirements--live, die and pay taxes.  And there is some truth to this old adage. If you are undocumented, have no papers, are living in the US having overstayed your visa, or having entered the US without inspection, I still recommend that you pay income taxes. Even if you do not have a social security number, you are still able to apply for an Individual Taxpayer Identification Number (ITIN) by filing Form W-7 with the IRS.  By paying income taxes, you create a record that you are living in the US.  This record of your continuous physical presence in the United States will be crucial if (when!) President Obama passes Comprehensive Immigration Reform.

• Never give your tax returns to USCIS or to an Immigration Judge unless you absolutely have to!  I've had several immigration cases where USCIS officers have reviewed my client's tax returns and have tried to draw all sort of unfair conclusions.  When this happens, suddenly, your immigration case turns into an impromptu tax audit conducted entirely by an immigration officer who may have little or no training in the complexities of the tax code.
  

Enjoy the beautiful weather today here in Boston, but make sure your taxes are in order first.  Good luck!

I was in Boston today at the Fundamental of Immigration Law Conference sponsored by the American Immigration Lawyers Association (AILA).  I spoke at a seminar entitled "Adjustment of Status and Consular Processing Workshop with the Experts--I-485, I-864, DS-230."

The immigration lawyers in attendance asked me some great questions, mostly about the I-864.  Here is some follow-up information:

1.  I-864, Affidavit of Support.  For questions on completing the I-864, I refer to an excellent 2006 USCIS memo available here which consolidated and revised USCIS policy regarding the I-864, Affidavit of Support.  Although more recent updated on the I-864, I find that this guide answers most basic questions.

2.  Public Charge and Public Benefits:  Your immigration clients may be concerned that if they accepts public benefits in the United States it could cause them immigration problems.  USCIS has published a guide available here that spells out which public benefits raise inadmissibility concerns under the public charge provisions of the Immigration and Nationality Act.  USCIS also put out a version of this guide specific to Massachusetts state benefits available here.

3.  Affidavit of Support (I-864) does not apply if the applicant seeking adjustment of status has worked or can be credited with working for 40 qualifying quarters, which can be documented by obtaining a certified Social Security earnings statement.  Information on how to obtain this statement can be found here.

I hope this information is helpful.  If anyone has a more specific immigration law questions, please call or email me.

As a lawyer specializing in deportation defense who frequently appears in Boston Immigration Court, I find it fascinating that a close family member of the President appeared yesterday in our court before our own Immigration Judge Shapiro.  Zeituni Onyango, the Kenyan aunt of President Obama, is in deportation proceedings in Boston as everyone on the populated Earth knows by now.

Of course, asylum applications are confidential.  I certainly have no direct knowledge about this case.  But my experience as a deportation lawyer in Boston tells me that Ms. Onyango's immigration case has been widely reported in a way that is quite misleading.  The headline of the Boston Globe, for instance, claims that the Immigration Judge allowed Ms. Onyango to stay in the U.S. until February 2010.  What is misleading about this headline is that it falsely suggests that the Immigration Judge made a discretionary decision in favor of Ms. Onyango.  This is not at all what happened at the hearing yesterday.

Allow me to explain.  But first, some background:  In 2004, according to press reports, Ms. Onyango applied for asylum and the Immigration Court in Boston denied her application.  As a result, she received an order of removal.  The Immigration and Nationality Act allows applicants to reopen removal proceedings where the applicant can present evidence of changed circumstances that could not have been presented at the prior hearing. My guess is that the immigration lawyer defending Ms. Onyango filed a motion to reopen and argued that the conditions in Kenya have changed in a way that would affect the merits of her claim.  A second and obvious argument as to changed circumstances is that Ms. Onyango would likely be a target if she were returned to Kenya because she is now well known as the aunt of the President of the United States. 

After Ms. Onyango filed her motion to reopen her order of removal, the Immigration Court in Boston had to make a discretionary decision as to whether to grant or deny the motion to reopen.  It is clear that the Court granted her motion to reopen because if it hadn't, she wouldn't have had to appear in Immigration Court.

What actually happened in Boston Immigration Court yesterdays is that, most likely, Ms. Onyango appeared at what is called a master calendar hearing.  A master calendar hearing is usually a brief, administrative hearing in which the Immigration Judge sets up the issues in contention and, typically, schedules a merits hearing at which these issues can be addressed.

So when the Boston Globe announced that Immigration Judge Shapiro allowed Ms. Onyango to remain in the U.S. until February 2010, what really happened is that she just showed up for a routine master calendar hearing and the Immigration Judge scheduled her to return for a merits hearing.  That's it.  The Immigration Judge didn't grant her a reprieve or approve her application for asylum.  This result gives us little indication about her prospects for success in immigration court.  It does tell us that the docket of Boston's Immigration Court is so full that asylum applicants need to wait almost 12 months to have their cases heard--even if your nephew is the President!